Re: GCD initialization and memory allocation HOBs


Laszlo Ersek
 

On 09/24/20 20:40, Jeff Brasen wrote:
It looks like CoreInitializeMemoryServices
(https://github.com/tianocore/edk2/blob/dd5c7e3c5282b084daa5bbf0ec229cec699b2c17/MdeModulePkg/Core/Dxe/Gcd/Gcd.c#L2116)
does not honor any memory allocations outside of the HOB list itself.
Should we add code to this function to make sure the region this
function select does not end up over a reserved region that the HOB
producer phase marked as already allocated? Either that or codify the
specific requirements a bit more on to make sure cases like this are
invalid. (producer might have to split up system resource entries,
etc)
Do you mean

(1) a physically reserved memory address range
(EFI_RESOURCE_MEMORY_RESERVED), or

(2) normal RAM (EFI_RESOURCE_SYSTEM_MEMORY) that is meant to be
"repurposed" (= pre-allocated) in PEI as a particular UEFI memory type?


EFI_HOB_RESOURCE_DESCRIPTOR "does not describe how memory is used but
instead describes the attributes of the physical memory present".

CoreInitializeMemoryServices() honors (1).

CoreInitializeMemoryServices() does not honor (2); however, the later
function CoreInitializeGcdServices() does honor (2).


* Regarding (1):

My understanding is that the HOB producer phase should describe
"physically reserved" memory regions with EFI_RESOURCE_MEMORY_RESERVED
resource descriptor HOBs, and these should not overlap normal memory
regions, which are described with EFI_RESOURCE_SYSTEM_MEMORY descriptor
HOBs.

Furthermore, whether (a part of) a memory resource is allocated or not,
is *orthogonal* to whether the memory resource is "physically reserved
memory" or "normal RAM". In my opinion, the diagram at

PI 1.7
Volume 2 (DXE Core Interface)
7.2.2 GCD Memory Resources
Figure 2. GCD Memory State Transitions

applies.

So the HOB producer phase should firstly describe the area in question
as EFI_RESOURCE_MEMORY_RESERVED (without overlapping any other resource
descriptor in memory address space).

Secondly, if the HOB producer phase wants to prevent DXE modules from
allocating reserved memory out of this resource, then the HOB producer
phase should *also* cover the entire range with a memalloc HOB
that uses EfiReservedMemoryType.

The first step above (= describing the area with an
EFI_RESOURCE_MEMORY_RESERVED HOB) will activate the following branch in
CoreInitializeMemoryServices():

//
// Skip Resource Descriptor HOBs that do not describe tested system memory
//
ResourceHob = Hob.ResourceDescriptor;
if (ResourceHob->ResourceType != EFI_RESOURCE_SYSTEM_MEMORY) {
continue;
}

* Regarding (2):

Normal (= not physically reserved) RAM that is allocated in PEI -- using
memalloc HOBs with various UEFI memory types, such as BS Data or AcpiNVS
-- is set aside in the CoreInitializeGcdServices() function.

Is that too late for your purpose? If so, why?

AIUI, CoreInitializeGcdServices() does make sure that DXE-phase calls to
gDS->AllocateMemorySpace(), gBS->AllocatePool(), and friends, will not
trample over the original memalloc HOBs.

Thanks,
Laszlo

Join discuss@edk2.groups.io to automatically receive all group messages.